Since the second Trump administration began we have been seeing a brazen increase in denials of care from pharmacists targeting, trans people getting their gender affirming care medications. There has been an aggressive push in allowing discrimination by healthcare professionals, and now the effects are being felt in our public schools. Since late September APS has been a part of a federal lawsuit attacking a public school student's right to socially transition without having to worry about parental notification. Most concerningly, this lawsuit was brought on by a teacher, Jeanette Martinez, a social worker for the special education department at an Albuquerque High School.
The lawsuit is based on Ms. Martinez personal belief that following APS policy, as all teachers and staff do, goes against her faith. Current APS policy allows students to socially transition while requiring teachers and staff not inform the guardians of said student and use the students dead name/pronouns while talking to the guardians, unless given explicit consent by the student. Ms. Martinez argues that not disclosing to the parents that their child is socially transitioning qualifies as lying, which goes against her Christian faith. Public schools across the nation with similar policies have been challenged by the current presidential administration already.
The right-wing non-profit funding Ms. Martinez’s lawsuit, Center for American Liberty, is a Virginia based organization that litigates for different conservative issues across the nation. Ms. Martinez and her team are arguing that concealing a student's social transition, even if it could put them in harm's way, is deceptive and places her in a moral dilemma since she claims she cannot lie due to her religion. She says not following the policy puts her job at risk but following it would be a violation to her First Amendment right of freedom of religion.
The request of this lawsuit, allowing teachers to bypass social transitioning policies depending on their deeply held beliefs, borders on mandated outing laws seen in 6 other states where, if found out, teachers are mandated to “out” the student to their family. Forced outing can put students in tremendous danger at home and cause lasting emotional scars. Fundamentally a teacher's job is to create and uphold a safe environment for all students no matter their feelings on any one specific pupil. Students need to feel comfortable to properly retain information and for many students school can double as a safe place depending on what their home life looks like. No matter personal beliefs, a teacher's job is to help and protect their students, not put them at risk due to personal deeply beliefs. Everyone should have their rights protected but if upholding someone's “right” harms another's freedom, the issue of “rights” ceases and the issue of legalized discrimination begins.